Doktor Jons Guide to the "Use and Application of CCTV"
- CCTV and Privacy issues -
If the truth be told, Doktor Jon is not that over enamoured at being constantly followed around the shops by second rate store detectives, but that's another story!
The point of course is that as with many aspects of modern life, we have absolutely no say on how or why our personal lives should be adversely influenced in the interests of so many, by the actions of so few.
If asked nicely, most people are more than willing to cooperate in some way for the greater good.
The time honoured argument of course, is that if youve done nothing wrong, then whats your problem?.
By initiating systems or procedures that inherently impact on our individual civil liberties, who is to say that the behaviour of a bio terrorist, or indeed a small time drugs dealer, will in any way be influenced by the issues that in consequence will affect the quality of life for us all.
If an individuals rights are to be significantly affected in the ongoing fight against terrorism, so be it; but perhaps its not unreasonable to expect a little bit of honesty and transparency to be introduced into the great scheme of things.
In fact, would it be unreasonable to suggest that if extraordinary sums of money continue to be invested in Public Space CCTV, then it should at least be 'fit for purpose'. The problem of course is that almost without exception, large actively monitored open space schemes are naively designed to operate on the basis of lottery surveillance, with generally sporadic observation of the law abiding, and little or no tangible effect on the longterm behaviour of the law defying.
If CCTV is to be widely deployed on the basis of providing enhanced public safety, then surely the public have a reasonable right to expect that the systems will actually make them safer. The problem of course, is that a succession of published research reports tend to suggest, that existing system designs are not having any significant impact on deterring criminal activity; so whilst the public may feel safer, in practice they are not.
Longterm experience tells us that the immediate benefit of crime reduction or displacement that results from the initial installation of any video surveillance system, generally evaporates through habituation, almost as quickly as the feel good factor from those who should have benefitted the most ... so where do we go from here?
IMPORTANT: No material may be reproduced, copied or redistributed from this site,
All the detailed information on this site is provided in good faith; as such, Doktor Jon does not accept responsibility for any consequential loss, injury or disadvantage resulting from any individual or organisation acting on the details contained herein.
© doktorjon.co.uk 2004 - 2009